Member Login

Ask-An-Expert  >   >  Why is arnica 30C ...


Default User Photo

Why is arnica 30C recommended by doctors for cosmetic surgery?

I?m really interested in alternative medicine and have had quite a few surgeries, I?m always telling friends to take arnica pills for example, because every surgery I?ve had a doctor has recommended homeopathy.

I decided to become a homeopath, looked at training and found it?s not really necessary as anyone can call themselves a homeopath.

Did lots of research and discovered it?s 100% water/ a sugar pill.

Homeopaths explanation is: magic

Scientific experiments indicate: placebo effect.

Apparently it?s so diluted that not even a single molecule exists in the final preparation, ie 1 part in 10,000 parts water! That?s like putting one drop of red food colouring (or vodka!) in 6 swimming pools worth of water, taking a cup out and expecting there to be any vodka in it!

But there?s a mystical magic way it?s prepared - apparently the more you dilute the stronger it becomes, you have to shake the water so many times and hit it with a piece of leather than bang it on a piece of wood and this is the explanation for why it still works even though one drop of the active substance has been diluted in approx 10,000 parts water.

I feel uncomfortable that I bleated on at so many friends to take arnica pills, I feel a bit dishonest now, knowing the truth of it. I think I got confused with herbs - of which there are a lot of that do work, but homeopathy is completely different.

The concept of like treats like, along with the magical dilution aspect of homeopathy is totally different from some herbal remedies like willow bark for example.

So doctors who recommend we take homeopathy either A) believe in magic or B) they are knowingly giving us sugar pills.

I don?t know what?s worse tbh. I would hate to be treated like a silly little woman by some paternalistic type doctor who is condescendingly giving me what he knows full well is magic water/sugar pills.

The alternative is a doctor who despite their scientific knowledge believes in the magical explanation of homeopathy.

Why did my surgeon tell me to take arnica 30c pills?

I got in touch with the homeopathy association to find out what 30C means. it's basically 1 part arnica in over a million parts water - there is no arnica left at all! They are 100% sugar pills.

Doctors/Professionals Only
Regular Users/Non-Professionals
  Notify me when a doctor/professional or regular member answers this question
  Notify me only when a doctor/professional answers this question

Learn more about



Welcome to the Ask An Expert section of our website! Our network of board certified physicians can answer any questions that you may have regarding plastic surgery, skin care, dermatology and other conditions. Popular topics include tummy tuck, liposuction, rhinoplasty, acne scars, facelift, breast augmentation and more. This frequently asked questions section is opened to everyone and you need to set up an account with Makemeheal before you can ask your own question. This service is absolutely free and is available to those who are interested in learning more about a particular cosmetic procedure, treatment or product.

Before asking a question, we recommend you to browse through our existing collection of questions and answers to ensure that the question you want to ask have not already been answered by our highly experienced experts. This will help you save time and get an answer more quickly. When asking a new question, we recommend you to be very detailed so that our experts could formulate a more precise & professional answer.

Of course, this service is not a substitute for a doctor visit or a consultation with a plastic surgeon or cosmetic dermatologist. The answer you will find here only serve as initial directions of thoughts and not as specific instructions. You should remember that it is utterly important to consult a skilled specialist prior to scheduling any type of treatment in order to get acquainted with possible contraindications. Only a one-on-one meeting will enable your cosmetic surgeon to properly evaluate your condition, conduct examinations and explain their results.